RRD:This time I will let Romney speak for himself.I have quoted the whole thing in context.
2012 ABC/Yahoo!/WMUR New Hampshire GOP primary debate (Transcript) - Election 2012 - The Washington Post
http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/election-2012/post/2012-abcyahoowmur-new-hampshire-gop-primary-debate-transcript/2012/01/07/gIQAk2AAiP_blog.html ”STEPHANOPOULOS: Governor Romney, do you believe that states have the right to ban contraception? Or is that trumped by a constitutional right to privacy?
ROMNEY: George, this is an unusual topic that you’re raising. States have a right to ban contraception? I can’t imagine a state banning contraception. I can’t imagine the circumstances where a state would want to do so, and if I were a governor of a state or...
STEPHANOPOULOS: Well, the Supreme Court has ruled -- (CROSSTALK) ROMNEY: ... or a -- or a legislature of a state -- I would totally and completely oppose any effort to ban contraception. So you’re asking -- given the fact that there’s no state that wants to do so, and I don’t know of any candidate that wants to do so, you’re asking could it constitutionally be done? We can ask our constitutionalist here. (LAUGHTER) (CROSSTALK) STEPHANOPOULOS: I’m sure Congressman Paul... (CROSSTALK) ROMNEY: OK, come on -- come on back... (CROSSTALK) STEPHANOPOULOS: ... asking you, do you believe that states have that right or not? ROMNEY: George, I -- I don’t know whether a state has a right to ban contraception. No state wants to. I mean, the idea of you putting forward things that states might want to do that no -- no state wants to do and asking me whether they could do it or not is kind of a silly thing, I think. (APPLAUSE) STEPHANOPOULOS: Hold on a second. Governor, you went to Harvard Law School. You know very well this is based on... ROMNEY: Has the Supreme Court -- has the Supreme Court decided that states do not have the right to provide contraception? I... STEPHANOPOULOS: Yes, they have. In 1965, Griswold v. Connecticut. ROMNEY: The -- I believe in the -- that the law of the land is as spoken by the Supreme Court, and that if we disagree with the Supreme Court -- and occasionally I do -- then we have a process under the Constitution to change that decision. And it’s -- it’s known as the amendment process. And -- and where we have -- for instance, right now we’re having issues that relate to same-sex marriage. My view is, we should have a federal amendment of the Constitution defining marriage as a relationship between a man and a woman. But I know of -- of no reason to talk about contraception in this regard. STEPHANOPOULOS: But you’ve got the Supreme Court decision finding a right to privacy in the Constitution. ROMNEY: I don’t believe they decided that correctly. In my view, Roe v. Wade was improperly decided. It was based upon that same principle. And in my view, if we had justices like Roberts, Alito, Thomas, and Scalia, and more justices like that, they might well decide to return this issue to states as opposed to saying it’s in the federal Constitution. And by the way, if the people say it should be in the federal Constitution, then instead of having unelected judges stuff it in there when it’s not there, we should allow the people to express their own views through amendment and add it to the Constitution. But this idea that justice... STEPHANOPOULOS: But should that be done in this case? ROMNEY: Pardon? STEPHANOPOULOS: Should that be done in this case? ROMNEY: Should this be done in the case -- this case to allow states to ban contraception?No. States don’t want to ban contraception. So why would we try and put it in the Constitution? With regards to gay marriage, I’ve told you, that’s when I would amend the Constitution. Contraception, it’s working just fine, just leave it alone. (LAUGHTER) (APPLAUSE) STEPHANOPOULOS: I understand that. But you’ve given two answers to the question. Do you believe that the Supreme Court should overturn it or not? ROMNEY: Do I believe the Supreme Court should overturn... (SOMEONE IN AUDIENCE YELLING) ROMNEY: Do I believe the Supreme Court should overturn Roe v. Wade? Yes, I do.”
2012 ABC/Yahoo!/WMUR New Hampshire GOP primary debate (Transcript) - Election 2012 - The Washington Post
http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/election-2012/post/2012-abcyahoowmur-new-hampshire-gop-primary-debate-transcript/2012/01/07/gIQAk2AAiP_blog.html ”STEPHANOPOULOS: Governor Romney, do you believe that states have the right to ban contraception? Or is that trumped by a constitutional right to privacy?
ROMNEY: George, this is an unusual topic that you’re raising. States have a right to ban contraception? I can’t imagine a state banning contraception. I can’t imagine the circumstances where a state would want to do so, and if I were a governor of a state or...
STEPHANOPOULOS: Well, the Supreme Court has ruled -- (CROSSTALK) ROMNEY: ... or a -- or a legislature of a state -- I would totally and completely oppose any effort to ban contraception. So you’re asking -- given the fact that there’s no state that wants to do so, and I don’t know of any candidate that wants to do so, you’re asking could it constitutionally be done? We can ask our constitutionalist here. (LAUGHTER) (CROSSTALK) STEPHANOPOULOS: I’m sure Congressman Paul... (CROSSTALK) ROMNEY: OK, come on -- come on back... (CROSSTALK) STEPHANOPOULOS: ... asking you, do you believe that states have that right or not? ROMNEY: George, I -- I don’t know whether a state has a right to ban contraception. No state wants to. I mean, the idea of you putting forward things that states might want to do that no -- no state wants to do and asking me whether they could do it or not is kind of a silly thing, I think. (APPLAUSE) STEPHANOPOULOS: Hold on a second. Governor, you went to Harvard Law School. You know very well this is based on... ROMNEY: Has the Supreme Court -- has the Supreme Court decided that states do not have the right to provide contraception? I... STEPHANOPOULOS: Yes, they have. In 1965, Griswold v. Connecticut. ROMNEY: The -- I believe in the -- that the law of the land is as spoken by the Supreme Court, and that if we disagree with the Supreme Court -- and occasionally I do -- then we have a process under the Constitution to change that decision. And it’s -- it’s known as the amendment process. And -- and where we have -- for instance, right now we’re having issues that relate to same-sex marriage. My view is, we should have a federal amendment of the Constitution defining marriage as a relationship between a man and a woman. But I know of -- of no reason to talk about contraception in this regard. STEPHANOPOULOS: But you’ve got the Supreme Court decision finding a right to privacy in the Constitution. ROMNEY: I don’t believe they decided that correctly. In my view, Roe v. Wade was improperly decided. It was based upon that same principle. And in my view, if we had justices like Roberts, Alito, Thomas, and Scalia, and more justices like that, they might well decide to return this issue to states as opposed to saying it’s in the federal Constitution. And by the way, if the people say it should be in the federal Constitution, then instead of having unelected judges stuff it in there when it’s not there, we should allow the people to express their own views through amendment and add it to the Constitution. But this idea that justice... STEPHANOPOULOS: But should that be done in this case? ROMNEY: Pardon? STEPHANOPOULOS: Should that be done in this case? ROMNEY: Should this be done in the case -- this case to allow states to ban contraception?No. States don’t want to ban contraception. So why would we try and put it in the Constitution? With regards to gay marriage, I’ve told you, that’s when I would amend the Constitution. Contraception, it’s working just fine, just leave it alone. (LAUGHTER) (APPLAUSE) STEPHANOPOULOS: I understand that. But you’ve given two answers to the question. Do you believe that the Supreme Court should overturn it or not? ROMNEY: Do I believe the Supreme Court should overturn... (SOMEONE IN AUDIENCE YELLING) ROMNEY: Do I believe the Supreme Court should overturn Roe v. Wade? Yes, I do.”
No comments:
Post a Comment